Sustainable Banking and Lending

Module 5: Sustainable Banking and Lending

The Role of Banks in Green Finance

Banks sit at the center of the financial system. They decide where capital flows—which projects get funded, which companies receive credit, and ultimately, which economic activities are enabled. This gives banks enormous influence over the transition to a sustainable economy.

The banking sector is responsible for financing a significant portion of global emissions. According to various estimates, banks' financed emissions exceed the emissions of many countries. This creates both responsibility and opportunity: banks that shift their lending toward sustainable activities can accelerate the transition while managing their own climate risks.

Evolution of Sustainable Banking

Early Phase (1990s-2000s)

• Environmental risk screening primarily to avoid liability
• Niche "ethical banks" serving values-driven customers
• Equator Principles established (2003) for project finance

Development Phase (2010s)

• ESG integration into credit analysis
• Green bonds and sustainable finance products emerge
• Voluntary commitments and disclosure frameworks
• Increasing regulatory attention

Mainstream Phase (2020s)

• Net-zero commitments from major banks
• Climate risk integrated into prudential regulation
• Mandatory disclosure requirements
• Sustainable finance embedded in strategy

The Equator Principles

The Equator Principles (EPs) were a pioneering framework for environmental and social risk management in project finance, adopted by banks since 2003:

Scope

Apply to project finance, project-related corporate loans, bridge loans, and project-related refinancing above certain thresholds.

Requirements

1. Environmental and social risk categorization
2. Environmental and social assessment
3. Applicable standards (IFC Performance Standards, World Bank EHS Guidelines)
4. Environmental and social management systems
5. Stakeholder engagement
6. Grievance mechanisms
7. Independent review for high-risk projects
8. Covenants requiring compliance
9. Independent monitoring and reporting
10. Reporting and transparency

The EPs have been adopted by over 130 financial institutions covering the majority of international project finance.

Green and Sustainable Lending Products

Green Loans

Loans where proceeds are exclusively used for green projects, similar to green bonds:

Green Loan Principles (established by LMA, APLMA, LSTA) mirror Green Bond Principles:

• Use of proceeds
• Project evaluation and selection
• Management of proceeds
• Reporting

Common uses: renewable energy, green buildings, clean transportation, sustainable water management.

Sustainability-Linked Loans

Loans with interest rates tied to sustainability performance:

Key Components:

• Sustainability Performance Targets (SPTs)
• Interest rate adjustment based on performance
• Reporting and verification requirements

Example: A company borrows at SOFR + 2.0%, with the margin decreasing by 0.05% for each sustainability target met.

Benefits: Flexible use of proceeds; incentivizes overall sustainability improvement; applicable to companies without specific green projects.

Sustainability-Linked Loan Principles provide market guidance on structuring.

Positive Incentive Loans

Various structures offering better terms for sustainable borrowers or activities:

• Preferential rates for green buildings
• Lower rates for electric vehicles
• Better terms for certified sustainable businesses

Integration into Credit Analysis

Leading banks now integrate sustainability into credit analysis:

Environmental Risk Assessment

• Exposure to physical climate risks
• Transition risk exposure (carbon intensity, regulatory risk)
• Environmental compliance and liabilities
• Pollution and waste management

Social Risk Assessment

• Labor practices and human rights
• Community relations
• Product safety and quality
• Supply chain issues

Governance Assessment

• Board oversight of sustainability
• Risk management processes
• Transparency and disclosure
• Business ethics

Impact on Credit Decisions

Sustainability factors can influence:

• Willingness to lend
• Pricing and terms
• Covenant requirements
• Monitoring intensity

Sector Policies

Many banks have developed sector-specific policies for high-risk industries:

Coal

Most major international banks have restricted coal financing:

• No new coal-fired power plants
• Phase-out timelines for existing coal exposure
• Exceptions (if any) for specific circumstances

Oil and Gas

Policies vary but often include:

• Restrictions on certain projects (Arctic drilling, tar sands)
• Due diligence requirements
• Support for transition plans
• Declining exposure over time

Deforestation

Policies addressing commodities linked to deforestation:

• Palm oil, soy, beef, timber
• Certification requirements
• Traceability expectations

Controversial Weapons

Exclusions on cluster munitions, landmines, nuclear weapons, etc.

Net-Zero Banking

The Net-Zero Banking Alliance (NZBA), convened by UNEP FI, commits member banks to:

• Align lending and investment portfolios with net-zero by 2050
• Set 2030 intermediate targets for priority sectors
• Annually disclose progress
• Support clients in their transition

This represents a fundamental shift from managing climate risk to actively using lending power to drive the transition.

Challenges

• Measuring and attributing financed emissions
• Setting credible sector pathways
• Balancing transition support with exclusions
• Managing client relationships
• Data availability and quality

Sustainable Trade Finance

Trade finance—supporting international trade through letters of credit, guarantees, and trade loans—is also greening:

Sustainable Trade Finance Products

• Green trade loans for sustainable goods
• Sustainability-linked supply chain finance
• Preferential terms for verified sustainable supply chains

Challenges

• Complexity of global supply chains
• Verification difficulties
• Fragmented data

Green Mortgages and Consumer Lending

Sustainability is entering retail banking:

Green Mortgages

• Better rates for energy-efficient homes
• Financing for energy efficiency improvements
• Incentives for green building certifications

Green Auto Loans

• Preferential rates for electric vehicles
• Often combined with manufacturer incentives

Other Consumer Products

• Green personal loans for home improvements
• Sustainable investment options in retirement accounts
• Carbon footprint tracking in banking apps

Regulatory Environment

Banking regulators increasingly focus on climate and sustainability:

Supervisory Expectations

Central banks and regulators have issued guidance requiring banks to:

• Integrate climate risk into governance
• Assess climate risks in credit portfolios
• Develop climate risk measurement capabilities
• Include climate in stress testing

Climate Stress Testing

Regulators in EU, UK, US, and other markets require banks to assess portfolio impacts under climate scenarios:

• Physical risk scenarios
• Transition risk scenarios
• Combination scenarios

Capital Requirements

Discussions ongoing about whether capital requirements should reflect climate risks:

• "Green supporting factor" (lower capital for green lending)
• "Brown penalizing factor" (higher capital for high-carbon lending)
• Concerns about mixing prudential regulation with climate policy

Challenges for Banks

Data and Measurement

• Limited data on borrower emissions
• Methodological challenges in financed emissions
• Scope 3 emissions particularly difficult

Transition Management

• How to support high-emitting clients in transition
• When to exit relationships
• Avoiding "impact washing" through early exit

Product Complexity

• Developing credible green products
• Avoiding greenwashing accusations
• Meeting diverse client needs

Talent and Capabilities

• Building sustainability expertise
• Integrating into existing credit processes
• Training relationship managers

Best Practices

For Banks

1. Develop clear sector policies with transition pathways
2. Integrate climate into credit risk frameworks
3. Set and disclose financed emissions targets
4. Offer differentiated pricing for sustainable activities
5. Engage with clients on transition planning
6. Build sustainability expertise across the organization

For Borrowers

1. Understand your bank's sustainability requirements
2. Develop credible transition plans
3. Provide quality sustainability data
4. Access green finance products where eligible
5. Engage proactively with lenders on sustainability

---

Next, we'll explore impact investing and measurement—how to quantify and verify the environmental benefits of green finance.