AI for HR & Recruiters

Module 9: Performance Review Templates

---

Module Overview

Performance reviews are among the most time-consuming and dreaded HR tasks. Managers struggle to write them, employees stress about receiving them, and HR spends endless hours on administration. AI can help make performance reviews more effective, fair, and less painful for everyone.

Learning Objectives:

By the end of this module, you will be able to:

• Create performance review frameworks with AI
• Write effective feedback using AI assistance
• Build development plans that drive growth
• Handle difficult performance conversations
• Improve review quality and consistency

Estimated Time: 45-60 minutes

---

9.1 The Performance Review Challenge

Why Reviews Often Fail

For Managers:

• Takes too much time
• Don't know what to write
• Avoid difficult conversations
• Worry about saying the wrong thing

For Employees:

• Feels like a surprise
• Too focused on recent events
• Vague or unhelpful feedback
• No clear path forward

For Organizations:

• Inconsistent quality
• Legal exposure from poor documentation
• Demotivating rather than developing
• Compliance check rather than growth tool

What Good Reviews Achieve

• Clear assessment of performance
• Specific, actionable feedback
• Aligned expectations going forward
• Development opportunities identified
• Documented conversation for the record

---

9.2 Review Framework Development

Competency-Based Framework

Create a performance review framework for [Job Title/Level].

Core competencies to assess:
1. [Competency 1]: [Brief definition]
2. [Competency 2]: [Brief definition]
3. [Competency 3]: [Brief definition]
4. [Competency 4]: [Brief definition]
5. [Competency 5]: [Brief definition]

For each competency, provide:
- Clear definition
- Rating scale (1-5 with descriptions)
- Behavioral indicators for each rating level
- Sample questions for self-assessment
- Sample questions for manager assessment

Also include:
- Overall rating calculation
- Guidance on avoiding rating bias
- Calibration considerations

Role-Specific Metrics

Create performance metrics for [Job Title].

Key responsibilities:
[List main responsibilities]

For each responsibility, define:
- Measurable outcomes
- Quality indicators
- How to assess if no clear metrics exist
- Weighting in overall assessment

Also suggest:
- How often to track these metrics
- Data sources for measurement
- Balance of quantitative and qualitative

---

9.3 Writing Performance Feedback

AI-Assisted Feedback Writing

Help me write performance feedback for an employee.

Employee context:
- Role: [Job Title]
- Time in role: [X months/years]
- Overall performance: [Exceeds / Meets / Below expectations]

Areas to address:
- Strengths: [List 2-3 key strengths with examples]
- Development areas: [List 1-2 areas for growth]
- Key accomplishments: [List significant achievements]
- Goals for next period: [If known]

Write feedback that is:
- Specific with examples
- Balanced but honest
- Forward-looking
- Actionable
- Professional and respectful

Length: 300-400 words per section (strengths, development, overall)

Strengths and Accomplishments

Help me articulate this employee's strengths for their review.

Context:
- Role: [Job Title]
- Strength area: [What they do well]
- Evidence: [Examples, metrics, feedback from others]

Write a paragraph that:
- Names the specific strength
- Provides concrete examples
- Quantifies impact where possible
- Explains why this matters
- Encourages continued development

Avoid generic praise ("great team player").
Be specific and meaningful.

Development Areas

Help me write constructive feedback on a development area.

Context:
- Role: [Job Title]
- Development area: [What needs improvement]
- Specific examples: [Situations where this showed]
- Impact: [How this affects performance]
- Potential causes: [If known]

Write feedback that:
- Names the issue clearly but respectfully
- Provides specific examples
- Explains the impact
- Suggests concrete steps for improvement
- Offers support and resources
- Expresses confidence in their ability to improve

Balance honesty with respect and encouragement.

---

9.4 Self-Assessment Support

Self-Assessment Questions

Create self-assessment questions for [Job Title].

Include questions about:
- Key accomplishments this period
- Challenges faced and how they handled them
- Skills developed
- Goals achieved/not achieved and why
- Development priorities
- Career aspirations
- Support needed from manager

Format as a form employees can complete.
Include guidance on how to answer each question.
Suggest word limits to keep responses focused.

Coaching Employees on Self-Assessment

Create a guide to help employees write effective
self-assessments.

Cover:
- Why self-assessment matters
- Common mistakes to avoid
- How to quantify accomplishments
- How to discuss challenges constructively
- How to propose development goals
- Template language for different scenarios

Include examples of:
- Strong self-assessment language
- Weak self-assessment language
- How to rewrite weak examples

---

9.5 Development Plans

Creating Development Plans

Create a development plan for an employee.

Context:
- Current role: [Job Title]
- Career goal: [Next role or skill goal]
- Key development areas: [1-3 areas]
- Timeframe: [6 months / 1 year]

For each development area, include:
- Specific development goal
- Actions to take
- Resources and support
- Timeline and milestones
- Success metrics
- Check-in schedule

Format as a document both manager and employee
can reference and update.

Skill Gap Analysis

Analyze the skill gap for this career transition.

Current role: [Title]
Target role: [Title]

Current skills:
[List current skills]

Target role requirements:
[List requirements]

Provide:
- Skills the employee already has
- Skills that need development
- Priority order for development
- Suggested learning approaches for each gap
- Realistic timeline for development

---

9.6 Difficult Performance Conversations

Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs)

Help me draft a Performance Improvement Plan.

Context:
- Employee: [Name]
- Role: [Title]
- Performance issues: [Specific issues]
- Previous feedback given: [When and what]
- Improvement needed: [Specific expectations]
- Timeline: [X days/weeks]

Include:
- Clear statement of performance concerns
- Specific expectations going forward
- Measurable success criteria
- Support and resources provided
- Check-in schedule
- Consequences if not improved

Tone: Clear, direct, but not punitive.
Focus on path to success, not failure.

Difficult Feedback Preparation

Help me prepare for a difficult performance conversation.

Situation:
- Employee: [Role and tenure]
- Issue: [Performance problem]
- Impact: [How it affects team/work]
- History: [Previous conversations]
- Goal: [Outcome you want from conversation]

Provide:
- Opening statement
- Key points to cover
- Anticipated employee reactions and responses
- Questions to ask
- How to close the conversation
- Follow-up documentation template

Keep tone constructive but honest.

Addressing Defensive Reactions

Give me language for handling defensive reactions
in a performance conversation.

Scenario:
- Feedback given: [What you said]
- Employee reaction: [How they responded]

Provide:
- Acknowledgment of their perspective
- Redirect to the facts
- Reframe to be constructive
- Questions to encourage reflection
- Path forward

Goal: Keep conversation productive without backing
down from accurate feedback.

---

9.7 Review Process Efficiency

Manager Guide Templates

Create a manager guide for completing performance reviews.

Include:
- Timeline and deadlines
- How to gather feedback
- Using the rating scale correctly
- Writing effective comments
- Common mistakes to avoid
- Calibration process
- Delivery expectations
- Documentation requirements

Format as a quick-reference guide managers can
use during review season.

Calibration Meeting Facilitation

Create a calibration meeting guide for managers.

Purpose: Ensure consistent ratings across teams.

Include:
- Meeting agenda and timing
- Ground rules for discussion
- How to present employees for calibration
- Questions to ask when ratings differ
- Decision-making process
- Documentation of decisions

Also include:
- Pre-work for managers
- How to handle disagreements
- Bias checks to incorporate

Feedback Aggregation Template

Create a template for aggregating 360 feedback
for performance reviews.

Sources to compile:
- Self-assessment
- Manager assessment
- Peer feedback
- Direct report feedback (if applicable)
- Cross-functional feedback

For each source, summarize:
- Key themes
- Specific examples
- Areas of agreement
- Areas of disagreement

Synthesize into:
- Overall performance narrative
- Clear strengths
- Development priorities
- Recommended actions

---

9.8 Rating Scale Best Practices

Creating Clear Rating Scales

Create a 5-point performance rating scale for our reviews.

Ratings should be:
- Clear and distinguishable
- Focused on behavior, not personality
- Applicable across all roles
- Actionable for development

For each rating (1-5), provide:
- Rating name
- Definition
- What this looks like in practice
- How common this rating should be
- Development implications

Include guidance on:
- Avoiding central tendency (everyone gets 3)
- Rating inflation
- Recency bias
- How ratings connect to compensation

Avoiding Rating Bias

Create a bias-check guide for performance ratings.

Common biases to address:
- Recency bias
- Halo/horn effect
- Central tendency
- Similar-to-me bias
- Confirmation bias
- Affinity bias

For each bias:
- Define it clearly
- Give an example
- Provide a question to ask yourself
- Suggest a prevention strategy

Format as a checklist managers use before
finalizing ratings.

---

Module 9 Summary

Key Takeaways:

1. Structure drives quality: Clear frameworks lead to better reviews.

2. Specificity matters: Vague feedback helps no one.

3. Balance is essential: Address strengths and development areas.

4. Development focus: Reviews should look forward, not just back.

5. Prepare for difficulty: Have language ready for tough conversations.

6. Consistency through calibration: Rating calibration reduces bias.

---

Preparing for Module 10

In the next module, we'll focus on training material creation. You'll learn to:

• Create training content efficiently with AI
• Build learning guides and courses
• Develop skill-building materials
• Make training engaging and effective

Before Module 10:

• Review your current training materials
• Note gaps in your training library
• Think about what training employees most need

---

"Great performance reviews don't judge—they develop. They don't surprise—they align. They don't demoralize—they motivate."

Ready to continue? Proceed to Module 10: Training Material Creation.