Green Finance Regulations and Standards

Module 7: Green Finance Regulations and Standards

The Regulatory Landscape

Green finance operates within an increasingly complex regulatory environment. Regulations serve multiple purposes:

• Prevent greenwashing and protect investors
• Create standardized definitions of "green"
• Require disclosure of climate and sustainability information
• Direct capital toward sustainable activities

Understanding this landscape is essential for anyone working in green finance.

EU Sustainable Finance Framework

The European Union has the world's most comprehensive sustainable finance regulatory framework:

EU Taxonomy

A classification system defining which economic activities qualify as environmentally sustainable:

Six Environmental Objectives:

1. Climate change mitigation
2. Climate change adaptation
3. Sustainable use of water and marine resources
4. Transition to circular economy
5. Pollution prevention and control
6. Protection of biodiversity and ecosystems

Criteria for Sustainable Activities:

• Substantially contribute to one or more objectives
• Do no significant harm (DNSH) to other objectives
• Meet minimum social safeguards
• Comply with technical screening criteria

The taxonomy provides detailed, science-based criteria for each sector and activity.

Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR)

Requires financial market participants and advisers to disclose:

Entity-Level:

• Integration of sustainability risks
• Principal adverse impacts (PAIs) of investments
• Sustainability-related policies

Product-Level:

• Article 6: Products not promoting sustainability
• Article 8: Products promoting environmental/social characteristics
• Article 9: Products with sustainable investment as objective

Products must disclose how they consider sustainability and their use of the taxonomy.

Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD)

Requires companies to report extensive sustainability information:

Scope: Large companies, listed SMEs, certain non-EU companies

Content: Based on European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) covering:

• Climate change
• Pollution
• Water and marine resources
• Biodiversity
• Circular economy
• Workforce matters
• Business conduct
• And more

Materiality: Double materiality—both impact of sustainability on the company and company's impact on sustainability.

EU Green Bond Standard

A voluntary standard for green bonds in the EU:

• Alignment with EU Taxonomy
• Detailed allocation reporting
• External review requirements
• Supervision framework

ISSB Global Standards

The International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB), established in 2021, has developed global sustainability disclosure standards:

IFRS S1: General Requirements

Sets foundation for sustainability-related financial disclosures:

• Governance
• Strategy
• Risk management
• Metrics and targets

IFRS S2: Climate-related Disclosures

Specific requirements for climate information, building on TCFD:

• Physical and transition risks
• Climate opportunities
• Scenario analysis
• Greenhouse gas emissions (Scope 1, 2, 3)
• Climate-related targets

ISSB standards are being adopted or considered by jurisdictions worldwide, potentially creating a global baseline for sustainability disclosure.

US Regulatory Developments

SEC Climate Disclosure Rules

The Securities and Exchange Commission has adopted climate disclosure requirements for public companies:

Requirements:

• Governance of climate risks
• Climate risk management processes
• Climate strategy and scenario analysis
• Greenhouse gas emissions
• Climate-related financial statement impacts

Scope: Phased implementation based on company size

State-Level Initiatives

California has enacted climate disclosure laws:

• Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (Scope 1, 2, 3 emissions)
• Climate-Related Financial Risk Act (climate risk disclosure)

These apply to large companies doing business in California, extending impact beyond state borders.

Other Jurisdictions

United Kingdom

• Mandatory TCFD disclosures for large companies and financial firms
• UK Green Taxonomy under development
• Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) for investment products

China

• Green bond guidelines and catalog
• Mandatory environmental disclosure for some companies
• Green credit guidelines for banks
• Developing transition taxonomy

Singapore

• MAS Guidelines on Environmental Risk Management
• Singapore-Asia Taxonomy for sustainable finance
• Mandatory climate disclosure under development

Other Markets

Japan, Australia, Canada, and many other countries are developing or implementing sustainable finance regulations, often building on TCFD and ISSB frameworks.

Green Taxonomies

Taxonomies define what qualifies as "green" or "sustainable":

Key Design Choices

Coverage: Which activities and sectors are included

Thresholds: How stringent are the criteria

Transition: How are transition activities treated

Social: Are social considerations included

Comparing Taxonomies

Different taxonomies can reach different conclusions:

• Nuclear power: Included in EU Taxonomy (under conditions), excluded in some other taxonomies
• Natural gas: Controversial inclusion as transition fuel in EU
• Forestry: Different approaches to what qualifies

Convergence Efforts

• Common Ground Taxonomy (EU-China)
• IPSF working on taxonomy interoperability
• ASEAN Taxonomy for Southeast Asia

Voluntary Standards and Principles

ICMA Principles

The International Capital Market Association maintains:

• Green Bond Principles
• Social Bond Principles
• Sustainability Bond Guidelines
• Sustainability-Linked Bond Principles

These voluntary principles are widely adopted and referenced by regulations.

LMA/APLMA/LSTA Principles

For lending markets:

• Green Loan Principles
• Social Loan Principles
• Sustainability-Linked Loan Principles

Equator Principles

For project finance environmental and social risk management.

Climate Bonds Standard

Certification standard for green bonds with sector-specific criteria.

Net-Zero Frameworks

Science Based Targets Initiative (SBTi)

Defines what constitutes a credible corporate climate target:

• Near-term targets (5-10 years)
• Long-term targets (by 2050)
• Net-zero standard requirements
• Sector-specific guidance

Net-Zero Alliances

Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero (GFANZ) umbrella includes:

• Net-Zero Asset Owner Alliance
• Net-Zero Asset Managers Initiative
• Net-Zero Banking Alliance
• Net-Zero Insurance Alliance

Members commit to aligning portfolios with net-zero by 2050.

Anti-Greenwashing Regulation

Regulators increasingly target greenwashing:

EU Approach

• SFDR requires substantiation of sustainability claims
• Taxonomy alignment must be disclosed
• Greenwashing is a supervisory priority

US Approach

• SEC scrutiny of ESG fund names and disclosures
• FTC Green Guides update under consideration
• State-level consumer protection actions

UK Approach

• Anti-greenwashing rule requires sustainability claims to be fair, clear, not misleading
• SDR limits use of sustainability-related terms
• FCA enforcement actions

Compliance Challenges

Data Availability

Meeting disclosure requirements often requires data that:

• Companies don't currently collect
• Is held by third parties (supply chain)
• Is uncertain or estimated

Methodological Questions

• How to calculate financed emissions
• How to assess taxonomy alignment
• How to conduct scenario analysis

Multiple Jurisdictions

Companies operating globally face:

• Different requirements in different markets
• Potential conflicts between frameworks
• Resource constraints in meeting multiple standards

Evolving Requirements

Regulations continue to develop:

• New frameworks being implemented
• Existing frameworks being revised
• Increasing stringency over time

Practical Guidance

For Companies

1. Map current state against emerging requirements
2. Invest in data collection systems
3. Build internal expertise
4. Engage with regulators and standard-setters
5. Plan for increasing disclosure requirements

For Financial Institutions

1. Understand product-level requirements (SFDR, SDR)
2. Develop taxonomy alignment assessment capabilities
3. Collect data from portfolio companies
4. Train investment and sales teams
5. Update policies and procedures

For Investors

1. Understand disclosure frameworks
2. Use standardized data where available
3. Recognize limitations of current disclosure
4. Engage for improved disclosure
5. Apply consistent analytical approaches

---

Next, we'll explore renewable energy finance—how solar, wind, and other clean energy projects are financed.